THE ABYSS
A Weimar Monarchy
Freud wrote that humans are
incapable of fully comprehending their own extinction. A similar incomprehension I believe can happen
on a much larger scale, that is with respect to whole societies, and this
denial is particularly pronounced in the Anglosphere democracies. The denial takes the form of reasoning that,
despite Trump and Brexit, the truly bad stuff cannot happen here. This
complacent reasoning has first to overcome the obstacle that the bad stuff is already happening, and secondly that simply
waiting for Trump’s term of office to expire or for Brexit to be done and
dusted will not do. The damage done, not least in the great divisions created,
will not disappear any time soon, indeed with respect to Brexit, we have not reached
anything like the nadir yet. Already the fascist trope about being stabbed in the back/betrayed by cosmopolitans’narrative is being promoted by hard-line Brexiteers. Whilst the coming economic
problems are unlikely to be laid at the door of those responsible. We face at least a decade of conflict, as the
consequences of Brexit play out.
To some extent we do not know what life will be like outside
the EU, - or for that matter any other major trading bloc, - except that it is
unlikely to be good. The real debate now is over just how bad. The most likely outcome
will be a recession; how deep or how long term depends on the power of the
economy to withstand the shock of exit. Experience does not make for optimism.
We could experience a perfect storm of inflation, sterling collapsing, a flight of
investment capital to the EU and elsewhere, unemployment rising and, with the
lost revenue making a hole in government coffers, cuts in services, services already
cut to the bone. The NHS will be particularly hard hit.
We would survive, but what kind of society will emerge from
such a scenario? Rising right-wing fascism and a growing gulf in wealth between
the rich few and the many will fuel bitterness and a sense of having been
robbed of the ‘benefits’ of Brexit. In
short we will become a sort of Weimar monarchy, with the steady encroachment of a vibrant,
nostalgic right, selling dreams of greatness, - once, of course, the chosen 'others'
are dealt with. The left a half-dead toothless
tiger, made rotten from within by Corbyn, will prove useless, indeed many
former Corbynites will switch their allegiance to the Right, who will have the
merit of looking like winners.
A nightmare scenario?
Perhaps, but do not imagine the UK is somehow immune to a slide toward
Orban/Erdogan/Putin, and of course Trump style fascism. We are already witnessing
some of the elements described above beginning to coalesce. Again, in short, we
are already dangerously close to the abyss.