COMMEMORATING WORLD WAR ONE IN MONOCHROME : DIARY NOTES: AUGUST 6TH 2014

Commemorating World War One in Monochrome


It is only two days since the start of events commemorating the start of World War One and I am already beginning to feel somewhat ‘war weary.’ As a passionate amateur historian it is not that I fail to recognise the significance of the centenary, few could fail to understand that. No, it is that I am becoming increasingly tired, indeed frustrated and irritated, by the ‘monochrome’ way in which the events of a hundred years ago are being both reported and commemorated. It is as if the black and white footage in which the period is recorded is being replicated in the way it is being remembered. A just war fought for “British Values,” to paraphrase the Prime Minister.
Well possibly, although one would have to state clearly what precisely those values were/are. Would those values be democracy? Tell that to the Indians, West Indians and Africans who fought and died in their thousands on all fronts, - whilst the Germans had a much wider franchise. Perhaps those values are standing up to bullies, defending the rights of small countries? This might have produced a hollow laugh from the Boers or any number of small African Kingdoms.   Free speech and liberalism perhaps? The suffragettes who had been force fed in prison and the hundreds of men imprisoned for conscientious objection to the war could have bust a gut over that one.
Wartime Propaganda. How much has
the narrative really changed. 

My point here is not to make a political point, but to highlight the lack of nuance and the continued parading of the ‘guilty Germans’ narrative, - a narrative I now believe to have been comprehensively demolished by the likes of the historians such as Christopher Clark and Sean McMeekin.*
 The war was a catastrophe of almost unimaginable proportions, with consequences still being felt to this day. Great Britain with its mixed messages and dithering during the July Crisis of 1914 bears some responsibility for this war; though to now watch media coverage in this country you would be hard to find any acknowledgement of this.
Put another way there was a moral case for going to war[1] on August 4th 1914, but things should never have got to that stage and Great Britain bore some of the responsibility that they had. A little humility and admission of this failure would not have gone amiss at some of the commemorative events. Instead we had smug self-satisfaction, most in-elegantly personified by the Prime Minister remarks.
Where are the tales of the young German boys from villages and towns across Germany being sent to their slaughter, or the Russian peasants propelled into Germany, badly led, badly equipped and with no idea of what it was they were supposed to be fighting for? Where are the portraits of the Czechs, Croats and Poles, conscripted into a struggle not their own? Or the Italians clinging to near vertical cliffs as they fought over small provinces of the Austro Hungarian Empire? In short where is the presentation of this immense tragedy outside of the prism of the ‘this sceptre’d Isle’ version of history?

No Gutter too Grubby



In a small footnote to the events taking place on Monday an obscene attempt was made by a grubby little band of political apparatchiks in the Tory party, – the so called ‘kill Mill’ unit – to use the event to try and discredit the Labour leader Ed Miliband. Miliband was set up, unlike the Prime Minister he was not given time to personalise the message on his commemorative wreath. This was used against him. No gutter too grubby then. In response I reproduce a poem that I composed a couple of years back when a similar disgusting ‘controversy’ sought to exploit the dead for political purposes.  
‘David Cameron has called the ban on England's footballers wearing poppies on their kit "outrageous".’ BBC News 09/11/11

Mr Cameron’s in a froth
And the Sun is seething hot
And they curse the foreign crowd
Who say the Poppy’s not allowed.

The dead don’t care,
The dead don’t care.

The Radio pundit can’t believe it
Who can possibly conceive it?
No Englishman can hide
From this blow to English pride.

The dead don’t care,
The dead don’t care.

So we summon up our Shakespeare
Stand our ground and make it clear
That our courageous footballers
Will wear the poppy here.

The dead don’t care,
The dead don’t care.


*See ‘The Sleepwalkers’ penguin books 2014 and McMeekin’s ‘The Russian Origins of the First World War’ Harvard Press 2013, respectively.  

[1] And also a strong moral case for staying out, though the German invasion of Belgium and the subsequent war crimes that they committed there made this case much harder to be heard. 

Popular posts from this blog

NESRINE MALIK AND THE UNSUNG VIRTUES OF HYPOCRISY

Image
As I write this a 27 year old woman, Mariam Ibrahim, has just had a baby in a Sudanese prison, ‘the condition of the mother and baby is not known as Ibrahim's lawyer and her husband, a US citizen, had been denied access to her. Omdurman women's prison has a basic clinic, where the child is thought to have been born. Ibrahim has been shackled since being imprisoned.’ [1]   Mariam also has an 18 month old child who is also being held in prison with her. The ‘crime’ for which she is imprisoned is apostasy, for which she has received the death sentence. She has also been sentenced to 100 lashes, for the additional crime of having sex with her Christian husband. Although she has been a lifelong Christian her father was a Muslim, Sudanese sharia law forbids women to marry outside the Muslim faith, men needless to say can do as they please in these matters. Mariam Ibrahim and her husband.  Nineteen countries punish their citizens for apostasy, and in 12 of those countries...
Read more

INTERVIEW WITH TOM VAGUE

Image
Tom Vague At the top end of All Saints Road there is a refuge, an enclave in which a local Bohemian culture retains a foothold, this is the Book & kitchen , a café/bookshop with adjoining terrace. Here the bustle of the nearby market gives way to conversation, conversation in the presence of images of the recent, and not so recent, past. The past of an area that has contributed so much to the life and culture of the city. I was there to meet local historian Mr Tom Vague a man intimately familiar with so much of this history. What Tom doesn’t know about the recent history of the area probably is not worth knowing. With Tom’s energy and effort Colville Community Forum, supported by City Living Local Life, recently held a gathering at The Book and Kitchen to celebrate this rich history. February 16 6-9 Pm, with Film Screening and Readings Exhibition February 16-26 2016. Featuring 30 Classic Westway Photographs and Posters. This represents one of a number of initiatives of t...
Read more

VOLINE AND TROTSKY

Волин и Троцкого A Footnote in Russian History In April 1917 the Russian anarchist revolutionary Voline* and Leon Trotsky were both stranded in New York as the Russian revolution broke out in Petrograd , inevitably coming into contact with one another. Voline stated that he felt that the Bolsheviks, given their ruthlessness and single minded determination, would ultimately come to power. They would then begin eliminating their opponents, amongst whom of course were the anarchists; this persecution would end with the Bolsheviks shooting the anarchists “like partridges.” Trotsky was dismissive, they might have their differences but they were comrades in arms, they had different interpretations of the revolutionary process but shared the same goals. It was nonsense to speak of Bolsheviks shooting revolutionary comrades, “we are socialists, comrade Voline! So we are not your enemies….” [1] In December of 1919, whilst gravely wounded Voline was captured by the Bolshe...
Read more